Accused rock-throwers also involved in earlier statue-hurling incident, prosecutors allege

A deadly night of drive-by rock-throwing, which shocked the Front Range last spring, may not have been the first for a couple of Arvada teenagers, prosecutors alleged in court filings.

Two of three suspects accused of killing an Arvada woman during a reckless rock-throwing spree at moving cars last April 19 have been charged with attempted murder for an earlier incident, this time involving hurling a statue.

Police now suspect that Nicholas Karol-Chik threw a concrete “Greek statue” head at a car, terrifying an Arvada family on April 1, just weeks before 20-year-old Alexa Bartell was killed when a landscape rock crashed through the windshield of her car in a rural area of Broomfield.

“We saw our car was all smashed and the driver’s side. All the lights — they were destroyed. It was big damage to the car. We were scared but not much we can do about it,” Ildara Bryan told Denver Gazette news partner 9News, referring to the statue hurling incident. “Half the statue was still in one piece and the rest was destroyed.”’

Alexa Bartell was killed by a rock thrown into her vehicle in April. The three suspects will each be tried separately, a judge ruled Friday. (Jefferson County Sheriff's Office)
Alexa Bartell was killed by a rock thrown into her vehicle in April. The three suspects will each be tried separately, a judge ruled Friday. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)

The Bryans were not hurt in the incident, which happened just weeks before Bartell died. Bartell was traveling on a remote two-lane highway near the Rocky Mountain National Wildlife Refuge when a large landscaping rock slammed into her windshield, killing her.

Prosecutors filed the additional charges of attempted first degree murder and attempted second-degree assault on Aug. 30. In motions filed by the prosecution obtained by The Denver Gazette, prosecutors said OnStar reports showed that Karol-Chik’s 2016 Chevrolet Silverado was in the vicinity of 82nd and Alkire around the same time the statue head was thrown.

Prosecutors also had cellphone records from Karol-Chik and Koenig that showed similar information, according to the court filings. The motions said that Karol-Chik is the one who did the throwing.

In response to the new charges, attorneys for the two suspects filed motions to delay an evidentiary hearing in the Bartell case set that is set for Friday afternoon. They argued that they want time to contact a defense expert who can speak to the OnStar and cellphone records.

Arrest documents showed that in the April 19 incident, at least six other cars were hit in a 45-minute span, injuring some victims and leaving others befuddled about what happened, even wondering if a wind storm had come through the area.

Prosecutors alleged that before they went on the second known incident, which killed Bartell, the three Arvada teenagers loaded up the back seat of a pickup truck with landscaping material and started throwing them at moving vehicles — at times pretending they were Marines hitting targets in a combat zone.

The arrest documents had described how the suspects used “Marine terms” before a rock was thrown and how the three teens each played a role: One drove, and the two others did the throwing from the moving truck, one of them yelling directions, such as “contact left” before a toss.

Jeffco sheriffs said that Bartell was on the phone with a friend when her voice went silent. The friend tracked her cellphone to the remote highway and found Bartell in the driver’s seat. When law enforcement arrived, they discovered Bartell in the front seat with no pulse, her “arm cold to the touch.”

Bartell’s front windshield had a hole in it, the back window was completely blown out, the affidavit said, and a rock with what appeared to be blood on it was found by the highway.

What followed was an intense investigation that involved an elaborate web of cellphone pings, witness interviews and even a query with a nearby Chevrolet dealership as to what kind of truck would have headlights that were seen on a surveillance video.

Zachary Kwak, the third person who was arrested in connection with Bartell’s death, does not face additional charges in the earlier statue-throwing incident involving the Bryan family.

Kwak, Karol-Chik and Koenig have all been charged with first degree murder in Bartell’s death.

A Jefferson County judge is expected to rule by tomorrow on whether the hearing will be continued to a later date.

Flowers were left near a field where Alexa Bartell's Chevy Spark drifted off the side of the road, 10600 Indiana St., after she was struck and killed by a rock thrown into her moving car. (CarolMcKinleyDenver Enterprise Reportercarol.mckinley@gazette.comhttps://denvergazette.com/content/tncms/avatars/5/c3/a0f/5c3a0fbe-1007-11ec-9e18-b7f42cfa4b0f.9565a0ce58866e86bcf18260621c2a46.png)
Flowers were left near a field where Alexa Bartell’s Chevy Spark drifted off the side of the road, 10600 Indiana St., after she was struck and killed by a rock thrown into her moving car. (CarolMcKinleyDenver Enterprise [email protected]://denvergazette.com/content/tncms/avatars/5/c3/a0f/5c3a0fbe-1007-11ec-9e18-b7f42cfa4b0f.9565a0ce58866e86bcf18260621c2a46.png)
FILE PHOTO: A memorial for Alexa Bartell, a 20-year-old Arvada woman who was killed when a landscaping rock was thrown through the windshield of her moving vehicle April 19, is set up at the fence around Westminster Hills Open Space where her vehicle was found, as seen on Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Broomfield, Colo. (Timothy Hurst/Denver Gazette) (TimHursttim.hurst@gazette.comhttps://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/aca82bd62b4ee425c598527cd6faa1b1?d=mm&r=g)
FILE PHOTO: A memorial for Alexa Bartell, a 20-year-old Arvada woman who was killed when a landscaping rock was thrown through the windshield of her moving vehicle April 19, is set up at the fence around Westminster Hills Open Space where her vehicle was found, as seen on Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Broomfield, Colo. (Timothy Hurst/Denver Gazette) ([email protected]://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/aca82bd62b4ee425c598527cd6faa1b1?d=mm&r=g)
Alexa Bartell's vehicle was hit by a landscaping rock which weighed 3-5 pounds. This photo was approved by her family to be released by the Jefferson County Sheriffs. (Jefferson County Sheriff's Office)
Alexa Bartell’s vehicle was hit by a landscaping rock which weighed 3-5 pounds. This photo was approved by her family to be released by the Jefferson County Sheriffs. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)
Susan Eckhardt visited a growing shrine at the fence near where Alexa Bartell's car came to a stop.
Susan Eckhardt visited a growing shrine at the fence near where Alexa Bartell’s car came to a stop. “It’s horrible. I hope they catch them. Someone’s got to know something,” she said. (Carol McKinley)

PREV

PREVIOUS

Biden FCC nominee on track for confirmation, opening path to net neutrality debate

The Senate is set to vote on President Joe Biden‘s nominee for the Federal Communications Commission, moving to fill a role that has been open for three years and give Democratic appointees a majority at the agency, likely restarting the debate over net neutrality. FCC nominee Anna Gomez is scheduled to be voted on by […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

Democrats weaponize Santos against vulnerable New York Republicans in new ad

House Democrats are launching their latest attacks against vulnerable Republicans in New York, seeking to tie a group of freshman lawmakers to one of the party’s greatest perceived liabilities: Rep. George Santos (R-NY). The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee aired a new video on Thursday targeting five freshman lawmakers they accuse of protecting Santos earlier this […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests