Aurora man suspected of killing homeowner days after collecting free furniture

The suspect met the victim for the first time through Freebies, an app for free items, before he shot him in the head, according to the arrest affidavit

The arrest affidavit for an Aurora man charged with murder last Friday shows he had met the victim to pick up free furniture before shooting him in the head a few days later.

On Friday, May 24, Aurora Police Department officers responded to a call of shots fired at a residence. Officers arrived at the scene and observed a black SUV leaving, and 45-year-old Aaron Paul Dafler in the driveway, unconscious, with a gunshot wound to his head. Dafler was later pronounced dead at the hospital.

The suspect, Gilbert Vermillion,43, was seen fleeing the scene in the black SUV, which led to a police pursuit. He was apprehended after rolling out of the moving car.

Vermillion had met Dafler and his girlfriend, Christina, through a post about free furniture on Freebie Alerts, according to the arrest affidavit. They were giving away household items because they were moving. During the week leading up to the incident, Vermillion visited their residence multiple times to pick up furniture.

According to the affidavit, Vermillion’s behavior escalated on May 24. He allegedly began to make unwanted advances to another person in the house. The family confirmed with 9NEWS, that it was Christina’s 15-year-old daughter.

In a police interview, the daughter said Vermillion made her extremely uncomfortable that evening. She said Vermillion asked her to look into his eyes and made her hold his hand for an extended period of time, on top of other inappropriate comments, and flirtatious gestures. Dafler told Vermillion to stop, which then escalated into a physical altercation.

Dafler de-escalated the situation, and Vermillion promised to leave and walked out the front door, according to the affidavit. However, Vermillion returned moments later, allegedly kicking the door down, looking for his phone and keys.

Despite Dafler repeatedly asking him to leave, Vermillion persistently re-entered the home to continue the confrontation. This ongoing altercation ultimately culminated in a fight in the driveway. A few moments later, neighbors heard gunshots and called police.

For more on this story, and others, visit The Denver Gazette’s news partner, 9News

FILE PHOTO: Jefferson County Sheriffs are looking for a person or persons who were involved in six instances where rocks were thrown at moving cars. The incidents occurred at: West Quincy Avenue and West Quincy Place; West Belleview Avenue and High Toll Trail; West Peakview Avenue and South Everett Way; West Bowles Avenue and South Jay; and West Coal Mine Avenue and South Webster Street. (AzmanL/iStock.com)
FILE PHOTO: Jefferson County Sheriffs are looking for a person or persons who were involved in six instances where rocks were thrown at moving cars. The incidents occurred at: West Quincy Avenue and West Quincy Place; West Belleview Avenue and High Toll Trail; West Peakview Avenue and South Everett Way; West Bowles Avenue and South Jay; and West Coal Mine Avenue and South Webster Street. (AzmanL/iStock.com)

PREV

PREVIOUS

Broncos sign WR Troy Franklin, have locked up all seven in 2024 draft class

The Broncos have locked up all seven members of their 2024 draft class. Wide receiver Troy Franklin, a fourth-round pick from Oregon, signed his deal Saturday after having been the only draftee not yet under contract. He got a four-year, $4.874 million deal that includes a signing bonus of $854,836. He will make the minimum […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

Adams State’s Romain Legendre, Gracie Hyde claim NCAA track titles | Colorado Sunshine

Where good news shines The Adams State duo of Romain Legendre and Gracie Hyde combined for three national titles last weekend at the 2024 NCAA Division II Outdoor Track and Field Championships in Emporia, Kan. Legendre claimed the title in the 5,000-meter run, while Hyde took home titles in the 1,500-meter and 3,000-meter steeplechase events. […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests